Monster Eye Pretzel Bites

I was scrolling through my blog’s Pinterest page last week and got an overwhelming feeling of sadness. I’m so proud of all the content I’ve created over the past EIGHT years but I can’t believe I’ve let this little blog go without a new post for three whole months!! I have been baking a lot, but just not getting around to photographing and sharing everything here on the blog as much. So I made a point of making something blog-worthy this weekend because I’m not ready to give up on Erica’s Sweet Tooth quite yet. I’ve dressed up one of the easiest (and tastiest!) desserts ever for Halloween in an effort to get myself back into the blogging game.

IMG_0182 (1) copy

Although I’ve never made the classic pretzel/Hershey kiss/M&M combo before, I’ve had them plenty of times and always love the sweet and salty treat. Whenever I bake for an event, I’m usually expected to bring a dessert that’s more involved, but if something so easy can be this cute, I’m not going to pass this up! I used Hershey hugs and orange candy melts with a combination of edible candy eyes that I got at Micheal’s and Target. So festive, a bit spooky, but totally cute!

IMG_0209 copy

Making this batch of pretzel bites literally took me a total of 20 minutes. And they’re so yummy! It was great to be behind the camera again getting creative with the styling and set up for the photos. I’m hoping this is something I can get back into the groove of, especially since the 8th anniversary of Sweet Tooth just passed a few weeks ago! Good thing it’s the high season of baking – Thanksgiving and Christmas will be here before we know it!!

Print Recipe
Save Recipe

Monster Eye Pretzel Bites


Square pretzels
Hershey hugs + orange candy melts
Edible candy eyes, variety of sizes


Preheat oven to 350 degrees and line a cookie sheet with parchment paper. Arrange pretzels in rows with a hug or candy melt on top. Place in the oven for 2 minutes, take them out, and immediately place candy eyes on top. Chill in the fridge until the chocolate is set.

IMG_0229 copy

IMG_0140 copy

Peach Crumb Bars

Every July I celebrate the abundance of peaches and nectarines with a complete over-indulgence of all stone fruits for as many weeks as possible. But somehow there are very few peach...

IMG_9186 copy

Oreo Truffle Cupcakes

Believe it or not I don’t have cookies and cream or Oreo cupcakes posted here on the blog. I did an epic Oreo cheesecake layer cake a few years ago with amazing...

IMG_9964 copy

Bunny Bait

It’s been way too long since I’ve made a new popcorn creation, and after I saw the idea of “bunny bait” floating around online, I knew it would make the perfect treat...

IMG_9614 copy

A lot has happened since I last posted – I entered a new decade and I’m a business owner! I purchased a pediatric dental practice in central Connecticut two weeks ago...

IMG_9021 copy

Valentine’s Day is a little over one week away and I’m celebrating properly this year with some rosé, champagne, and red wine gummy bears! I saw the rosé version on Sprinkles...

IMG_7921 copy

Funfetti Buttercream

While I did have a few “semi” healthy recipes lined up to share in the month of January, things got busy (story of all our lives!) and here I am on...


Christmas Tree Cupcakes

Christmas trees! Stupidly big, colorful, sparkly, and over the top. That’s just how I like em. I’ve seen this idea of using frosting to decorate ice cream cones to make Christmas...


Mini Pumpkin Cheesecakes

I think I have officially exhausted my capacity for creating pumpkin treats this fall. I spent the month of November on a pumpkin muffin-making extravaganza. I wanted to introduce myself to...


Monster Cookie Sandwiches

If you’ve been reading this blog for some time, you know how much I adore Halloween desserts. There are SO many options, both scary and creepy, that all get the imagination...